The Economics of Informality Conference 2018
URI permanente para esta colección
The conference will be the first organized by the “Network on Informality Studies” at Universidad del Rosario.
The school of Economics at Universidad del Rosario (Bogota, Colombia) is pleased to invite you to The Economics of Informality Conference 2018. This Conference aims to bring together scholars, experts, young researchers, practitioners and policy makers to present their work and exchange knowledge and debate the issues about informal economy.
Examinar
Examinando The Economics of Informality Conference 2018 por Fecha de publicación
Mostrando1 - 20 de 30
Resultados por página
Opciones de clasificación
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoHeterogenous e ects of informality: An application to labor regulation policy in Russia(2018-05-28) Otero, Andrea; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018The paper estimates the heterogeneous returns of informality in Russia. The em-pirical strategy uses a Marginal Treatment Effect model (MTE). The data comes fromthe Russian Longitudinal Monitoring Survey (RLMS) and a combination of regionaldata for the period 2009-2016. I also constructed a measure of enforcement of laborregulation at the regional level that allows me to identify the parameters of the MTEmodel. I find that formal workers have, on average, 20% higher wage rates than in-formal workers. Additionally, the MTE has a negative slope, which reflects the factthat individuals with a higher propensity score of being formal are those who are morelikely to work formally -they have the largest positive gains of this type of jobs on theirearnings. My estimates also show that those individuals with a very low propensityof working formally can be negatively affected by having these types of jobs. Thesefindings suggest that the decision of working formally versus informally responds toa comparative advantage story and not segmentation of the labor market/ability hy-pothesis.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoStrict Duality and Overlapping Productivity Distributions between Formal and Informal Firms(2018-05-28) Schipper, Tyler C.; Allen, Jeffrey; Nataraj, Shanthi; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018This paper develops a multi-industry general equilibrium model where en-trepreneurs within each industry can decide to operate formally or informally.The model yields a rich set of predictions about how firms interact in the econ-omy. It reconciles the seeming contradiction between the canonical model ofstrict productivity dualism and the empirical literature that shows an aggre-gate overlap in productivity across the formal and informal sectors. We showthat this “contradiction” is a natural outcome of fixed costs varying acrossindustries. Our model is consistent with a set of stylized fact derived fromWorld Bank Enterprise Surveys. They show that 51% of formal firms reportcompeting with informal firms. Competition decreases with a country’s de-velopment, and larger firms face less competition from informal firms. Thesefacts, in tandem with out model, highlight the complexity of informality indeveloping countries.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoFormal Employment is a Consequence of Skill Diversity in Cities(2018-05-28) Chaparro, Juan Camilo; O'Clery, Neave; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018Why do cities with larger populations in developing countries create relatively more formal employment? We build a model where skill diversity increases with working age population size, and urban agglomeration economies result from complementarities at the firm level between workers with diverse skills. Inactive, unemployed,or self-employed (informal) workers are gradually absorbed by firms as new sectors appear via an evolutionary process ofskill recombination by firms.The model makes four predictions: (1) faster firm entry in less complex sectors, (2) higher wages in more complex sectors, (3) relatively more formal employment in larger cities, and (4) faster formal employment growth in cities that have more of the skills needed in more complex sectors. Since skills are not observable, sector complexity is computed from sector diversity and ubiquity, and skill availability from inter-industry labor transitions. We find strong empirical support for all of the predictions when tested with social security data for Colombia for the period 2008-2015.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoWho pays? The distributional impacts of slowing economic growth in Latin American labor markets(2018-05-28) Sousa, Liliana; Reyes Ortíz, Giovanni Efraín; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018After a decade of strong growth and notable poverty and inequality reduction, Latin America finds itself in a pattern of regional slowdown. What, if any, are the distributional impacts of the slowdown? We study over 6 million labor market transitions from Argentina, Brazil, Mexico, and Peru to analyze how urban employment dynamics have adjusted to fluctuations in growth over the past decade. In particular, we focus on adjustments to labor market transitions to see if certain transitions, such as movements from employment to unemployment or from formal to informal work, are more sensitive to changes in growth and if some types of workers are more vulnerable to these changes. The results suggest that the emerging economies in this study have not shown significant changes in labor market transitions during the current growth slowdown. However, exploiting a decade of panel data of quarter-to-quarter transitions, we identify some sensitivity of labor market transitions to changes in growth and find that workers in low income quintiles are more likely to experience negative labor transitions than workers in high income quintiles during low growth periods.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoIlluminating the shadows in U.S. States(2018-05-29) Dincer, Oguzhan (Oz); Adhikari, Bibek; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018What forces the businesses to hidein the shadows? There are two competing theories trying to explainthis behavior, one identifying high tax burdenand the other corruptionas the main force.As Friedman et al. (2000) and Dreher et al. (2008) argue, according to the first theory, businesses are simply not willing to pay high taxes and keep all of their profits to themselves. According to the second theory, they are actually willing to pay taxes, but not willing to pay bribes.In this study, we investigate the relationship between corruption and the size of the shadow economy in U.S. states using a new and novel Shadow Economy Index (SEI) which is developed based on satellite data on night lights.We find that there is a complementary relationship between corruption and the size of the shadow economy across U.S. states supporting the results of Johnson et al. (1998) and Friedman et al. (2000) which use cross country data.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoBank Account Ownership by Micro-entrepreneurs in Mexico(2018-05-28) Rodríguez Zamora, Carolina; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018This paper evaluates the impact of a VAT rate increase on bank account ownershipby Mexican micro-entrepreneurs considering informality as the main channel of this effect. Using two rounds of a cross-section survey aimed at understanding financial inclusion in Mexicoand a difference-in-difference strategy, results indicate that an increase in the VAT rate negatively affects the probability of having a bank account by micro-entrepreneurs in northern municipalities where the tax rate increased from 11 to 16 percent. In particular, financial inclusion of micro-entrepreneurs in the northern border decreased and the effect is statistically significant,whereas financial inclusion of formal and informal salaried workersin the northern borderdid not change as their fiscal obligations remained the same with the VAT amendment.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoOptimal Monetary policy with Informality: A Benchmark Framework(2018-05-28) Gómez, Mónica A.; Hairault, Jean-Olivier; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018Our paper aims at unveiling how much the monetary policy shall deviate from the zero-inflation allocation in an economy with a large informal sector. A first insight is thatinformality amplifies cost-push shocks on inflation. The gap between the natural rateand the first best allocation varies due to both fluctuations in tax distortion and sectoralmisallocation. In both channels, the size of informality is key for the magnitude of thecost-push shock, and with it the cost of business cycles. It happens that the higher thelevel of informality, the larger the business cycle costs are. A second insight is relatedto how the monetary policy should optimally spread these costs in terms of inflationand output gap volatility, and how it depends on the informality size. It is shown thatthe aggregate sacrifice ratio (in terms of a weighted average of the sectoral output gaps)increases with the size of the informal sector. This leads to recommend less inflationstability in an economy with a large informal sector. The last insight is that monetarypolicy should not target one particular sector as there is a sectoral integration condition.Only considerations related to informational issues could lead to recommend to favor theformal output gap in the monetary rule
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoThe Informal sector and economic transformation in India(2018-05-28) Kesar, Surbhi; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018In the literature on development and modernization, it has been expected that with economic growth and a consequent increase in per capita income, the dualism between the formal and informal economic sectors will wither away, leading to a structural transformation and formalization of the economy. However, in India, in spite of a long period of sustained economic growth, the informal sector has continued to persist and to provide employment to a vast majority of the population. The interaction of informal economy with the process of economic growth has been widely debated in the literature from two competing perspectives – (i) the segmentation / dualist views, which sees the informal economy as a residual sector that absorbs the excess labour force in the economy. This view supports the ‘need’ for a transition towards a full-fledged formal/ ‘modern’ economy as the ideal path of development (Ranis and Stewart, 1999; Mandelman and Montes-Rojas, 2009; La Porta and Shleifer, 2014); and (ii) the micro-entrepreneurial view, which sees the informal economy as dynamic in nature, with risk taking and profit-maximizing enterprises that can act as the engines of economic growth. This strand views the self-employment in informal sector as the seedbed for modern capitalism in the Third World countries, thereby implicitly arguing that the issue of transformation is already resolved (De Soto, 1989; Fajnzylber et al, 2006). It has been further argued that the informal economy might be the preferred destination for the workforce than being employed as formal salaried workers (Maloney, 2004). On the other hand, there has been a concern that has also been raised about a possible stalling of the transformation process across developing economies (Timmer & Akkus, 2008; DeVries et al, 2012). Specifically, in the Indian context, some recent works have argued that the growth process has been largely exclusionary, leaving out a major part of the workforce outside the dynamics of transformation (Sanyal, 2007; Bhaduri, 2017), while it has also been argued that if the growth process can be made more inclusive, it would eventually lead to a large scale transformation of the Indian economy (Bardhan, 2009).
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoInformal sector employment and poverty in South Africa(2018-05-29) Cichello, Paul; Rogan, Michael; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018We examine the role that informal sector employment plays in poverty reduction using data from the National Income Dynamics Study (NIDS). Using a Shapley decomposition approach, wefind that government transfers and formal sector jobs are the dominant drivers of aggregate poverty reduction. Informal sector jobs currently play a limited role in poverty reduction at the national level. This is primarily driven by the fact that there are relatively few informal sector jobs compared to formal sector jobs. On a per-job basis, the poverty reduction associated with formal sector jobs and informal sector jobs is quite similar. The poverty reduction associated with one informal sector job is generally between 50 to 100 per cent of the poverty reduction associated with one formal sector job (depending on the poverty measure, poverty line and year chosen). Therefore, from a poverty reduction standpoint, policy makers are encouraged to view job gains and losses in the informal sector approximately on par with gains and losses of formal sector jobs.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoShadow Economies Around the WorldWhat Did We Learn Over the Last 20 Years?(2018-05-29) Medina, Leandro; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018We undertake an extended discussion of the latest developments about the existingand newestimation methods of the shadow economy. New results on the shadow economy for 158 countries all over the world are presented over1991 to 2015. Strengths and weaknesses of these methods are assessed and a critical comparison and evaluation of the methods is carried out. The average size of the shadow economy of the 158 countries over 1991 to 2015 is 31.9percent. The largest onesare Zimbabwe with 60.6percent,andBolivia with 62.3percent of GDP. The lowest ones are Austria with 8.9percent, and Switzerland with 7.2percent. The new methods, especially the new macro method, Currency Demand Approach (CDA) and Multiple Indicators Multiple Causes (MIMIC)in a structured hybrid-model based estimation procedure, are promising approaches from an econometric standpoint, alongside some new micro estimates. These estimations come quite close toothers used by statistical offices or based on surveys.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoSocial assistance and informality: Examining the Link in Colombia(2018-05-28) Ospina, Mónica; Saavedra, Fabiola; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018This paper presents evidence on the labor market effects of social assistance programs in the short and medium run. We evaluate the impact of a Conditional Cash Transfer (CCT) program “Familias en Acción” on informality at the individual level in Colombia. We include three different perspectives on informality that capture different aspectsof the problem. We argue that even though it is not a desirable result, being a beneficiary of social programs may create perverse incentives towards informality. Weused survey data from the “Familias en Acción” program to identify whether the program had any effect on workers’ propensity to participate in the informal labor market in Colombia both one and four years after the program’s implementation. Toovercome the problem of unobserved time-invariant differences, our empirical strategy includes a combination of matching algorithms and difference-in-differences methodology. Our results show that worker’s informality condition may be affected by receiving CCT income.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoSolving the Puzzle between the Minimum Wage and (In) formal Employment: An Analysis for a Developing Economy(2018-05-28) Arango, Salomé; García, Gustavo A.; Posso, Christian; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018This paper examines the effects of the minimum wage on employment, as well as other labor market outputs such as (in)formality, inactivity and hours of work. We use a data panel from 2009 to 2016 from the main regions of Colombiaand exploitthe exogenous variation of the minimum wage to isolate the effects of the simultaneous determination of employment and wages. The results show that the minimum wage negatively affectsboth formal and informal employment, which implies a decrease in the employment rate.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoFinancial disincentives for formal work in Ecuador and Colombia(2018-03-28) Rodríguez, David; Jara, Xavier; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018High and persistent labour informality has been a major problem for Latin American economies where most workers are excluded from social protectionandhave low and variable incomes.In the case of Ecuador and Colombia, despite recent formalisationpolicies, there is still a long way aheadto reduce informality which affects near half of the workforce.This paper seeks to quantifythe role of tax and benefit systems on financial incentives to enter formal work.In order to do so, weassess the formalisationcosts for Ecuadorian and Colombian informal workers using multi-country tax-benefit microsimulation techniques. In particular, we make use of representative microdata and simulate transitions from the informal into the formal sector to calculate the proportion of earnings that will be taxed away in the form of increased taxes andsocial insurance contributionsor reduced cash transfers, when a worker enters formality. We test the sensitivity of our results to different assumptions about the wage level individualswouldface when entering the formal sectorwith several imputation strategies.Our findingsshow that financial costs of formalisation are almost equaltopossible labour income gainsafter a transition to the formal sector. In other words, despite counterfactual formal income is in most of the cases higher than in the informal sector,the design of the tax system, and particularly, of social insurance contributions, erase mostpotential monetary gains of such a transition. This is espe-ciallytrue for self-employment workers.Furthermore, assuming workers self-select into the sector offering a comparative advantage we find even higher formalisations costs.Lastly, taking into account compliance with minimum wage legislation labour income gainsare muchhigher than using only counterfactual estimates, however,formalisation costs do not decrease substantially.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoInformality and segmentation : evidence from a self-selection model with entry barriers to formal employment in Peru(2018-05-28) Alvarado Enciso, Alfredo M.; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018The academic debate about informality has discussed whether this implies a segmented labor market, a competitive one or a mixed of both. Recent research has employed various empirical models in order to validate those hypothesis.However, it has not been possible to correct several deficiencies such as the use of earning equation, exogenous specification of labor segments and endogeneity by self selection. The present paper correct this constrains by using a self selectionmodel with entry barriers to formalemployment. It is concluded that there is indeed a multi-segmented labor market and that about a third of informal workers are involuntary
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoHow vulnerable are the self-employed? Evidence from Uganda(2018-05-28) Lakemann, Tabea; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018Due to small firm sizes and inter-linkages between household and business finances, small-scale entrepreneurs in developing countries are inherently vulnerable to temporary and per-manent income shortfalls, and hence household poverty. While the ILO generally defines self-employment without employees as vulnerable employment, little empirical research has beendone on the extent to which the self-employed are indeed vulnerable. This paper makes twomain contributions: first, it operationalises the concept of vulnerability in the context of self-employment in developing countries by defining vulnerability as the risk of having businessincome below a living wage threshold. Secondly, it investigates the extent and correlates ofvulnerability. Using a balanced entrepreneur panel dataset from Kampala, Uganda, it is shownthat the self-employed are heterogeneous with respect to vulnerability and observed earnings:while close to 70% of the sample are vulnerable and mostly earn incomes below the threshold,about 30% are non-vulnerable and mostly earn incomes above the living wage. Vulnerable en-trepreneurs are shown to be significantly different from non-vulnerable entrepreneurs in severaldimensions, including those that do not directly predict income.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoOptimal Redistribution with a Shadow Economy(2018-05-28) Doligalski, Pawel; Rojas, Luis E.; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018We extend the theory of the optimal redistributive taxation to economies with an informal labor market. The optimal tax formula contains two new terms capturing reported income responses of informal workers on an intensive and an extensive margin. Both terms decrease the optimal tax rates. We quantitatively show that this reduction can be substantial, exceeding 30 percentage points, and we document a large welfare gain of up to 6.4% of consumption from following our tax formula rather than the standard formula. We also provide a novel decomposition of the welfare impact of the shadow economy into labor eficiency and redistribution components. In the quantitative model estimated with Colombian data the shadow economy benefi ts efficiency at the expense of redistribution. As a result, conditional on the optimal tax policy, the presence of the informal sector does not substantially affect social welfare unless social preferences for redistribution are strong.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoExploring the role of health in Early Retirement by occupational status: looking for the causes of the greying of the self-employed sector(2018-05-28) Arévalo, Paola P.; Concepción, Román; Congregado, Emilio; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018This paper investigates the relationship between early retirement and health by using a discrete duration model in order to check if some differences across employment status emerge. Using the European Community Household Panel (henceforth ECHP) covering the period 1994-2001, this work produces new empirical resultson the effect of the self-perceived health state to the decision to early retirement. The main hypothesis was to find differences between paid-employees and self-employees, however our results point to how the potential effects of health on the early retirement decision could be circumvented in paid-work thanks to employment protection legislation (for paid-employees) whereas in self-employment the real health status is a key determinantonthis decision.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoEffects of pension benefits on pre-retirement labor supply: Evidence from Chile(2018-05-29) Becerra, Oscar; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018This paper describes the effects of pension benefits on pre-retirement labor supplyfor a representative sample of Chilean workers. Using non-linearities in benefits and areform that changed non-contributory pensions, I estimate the effect of pension wealthand pension accrual rate on labor force and contributory-sector participation, earnings,and hours worked. I find that the response of labor supply to future pension benefitsis mostly through the effect of the pension accrual on the probability to contributeto the pension system. My results suggest that pension benefits affect labor supplyallocation, an effect that should be considered in the design of pension reforms.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoConstrained occupational choice(2018-05-29) Margolis, David; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018This paper uses a reduced-form implementation of a structural model of constrained oc-cupational choice to explain the probability that an individual receives a wage offer, animportant determinant of whether self-employment is by choice or necessity. Using datafrom Sierra Leone in 2016, the paper estimates the model and finds that the unconditionaldistribution of offer probabilities has a large spike at a very low value (0.013), but that cer-tain characteristics, such as education, being male and residence in the capital city increasethe likelihood of being able to choose not be self-employed.
- ÍtemAcceso AbiertoA Bonanza for Bad Politicians: Informal Gold Mining and Criminal Candidates in Peru(2018-05-29) Bandiera, Antonella; The Economics of Informality Conference 2018How do natural resource windfalls affect the quality of politicalcandidates? Existing scholarship argues that non-tax public revenuehas a negative effect on the characteristics of candidates because itimpairs the capacity of voters to hold leaders accountable. This liter-ature, however, has not considered other non-tax sources of revenue,namely, the rents derived from the informal and illegal exploitation ofnatural resources. In this paper, I analyze the effects of an increaseof informal gold production in Peru. I find that in districts that havehigher levels of informal gold mining, increases in prices worsens thequality of politicians. In particular, I use novel data on the crimi-nal records of candidates to show that a spike in the price of goldattracts more criminal candidates to politics and leads elected politi-cians to be accused of committing a crime more often. Interestingly,I also find that candidates who have a criminal record are less likelyto be elected. These results suggest that information on the trajec-tories of politicians is key to improve the quality of candidates that will be elected, and that the enforcement of natural resource regula-tion is crucial to eliminate the influence of rents on the behavior ofpoliticians.